phone-icon Call Us Now
The toughest Roads
shouldn't be navigated alone
shouldn't be
navigated alone
Let's get you back
on the road legally
boder-line-b
Attorney Brian Simoneau is a great lawyer. He is very versed on the current laws and he will help you convey a well organized winning case. I would highly recommend him.
James F.
c-img-new c-img-new

Hardship License Denial Reasons in Massachusetts

The Massachusetts Board of Appeal has the authority to override the Registry of Motor Vehicles’ denial of a hardship license and order the RMV to grant a license, even if the Registry initially refused. However, the Board only grants hardship licenses when the majority of members determine that the applicant has a legitimate hardship and that granting the license will not compromise public safety. There is no automatic right to a hardship license in Massachusetts, and obtaining one is considered extraordinary relief.

It is essential to understand the most common reasons the Board may deny a hardship license so you can properly prepare your case.

1. Insufficient Documentation Supporting Hardship

The Board requires all hardship license requests to be supported by thorough documentation that demonstrates your need to drive and addresses public safety concerns. This includes evidence of employment, medical appointments, school attendance, or other circumstances that make a license essential. Applicants who fail to provide adequate documentation are unlikely to succeed.

2. Other Transportation Available

A hardship license is intended to be a last resort. If public transportation is available or friends, family, or coworkers can provide rides, the Board will generally deny your request. Your case must clearly show that driving is essential and that no reasonable alternatives exist for work, school, or medical purposes.

3. Open or Pending Criminal or Civil Cases

If you have unresolved criminal or civil cases that could result in future license suspensions, the Board will typically refuse to hear your hardship appeal until those matters are resolved. Granting a license under these circumstances would be counterproductive, as any new convictions could trigger additional suspensions.

4. Evidence of Operating During Current Suspension(s)

Applicants who have recently driven while their license was suspended or revoked face a high likelihood of denial. The Board views such behavior as a conscious disregard for the law, and it strongly weighs this when considering hardship relief. In some cases, satisfactory explanations or mitigating circumstances may help, but recent violations significantly reduce the chances of approval.

5. Multiple Active Suspensions

Having multiple suspensions in effect simultaneously can make obtaining a hardship license extremely difficult. The Board is cautious in these situations, and attorneys often advise clients to wait until older suspensions expire before applying to increase their chances of success.

6. Prior Hardship Relief Granted

If you have previously received a hardship license from the Board, you are less likely to receive relief in the future. Hardship licenses are considered extraordinary, and repeated requests are generally viewed with skepticism, especially if there is any record of re-offense while under a prior hardship license.

7. Poor or Lengthy Driving Record

The Board reviews your complete driving and criminal record when considering a hardship license. Applicants with extensive histories of suspensions, revocations, or repeated operating-after-suspension offenses face an uphill battle. Long or problematic records significantly reduce the likelihood of approval.

8. Board Discretion

The Board is not required to grant a hardship license, even if all other criteria are met. Its decisions are purely discretionary, and members may deny a license based on their judgment, even when an applicant demonstrates a legitimate hardship and provides thorough documentation. Courts defer to the Board’s expertise, and no court has the authority to compel the issuance of a hardship license.

Appealing a Denial by the RMV

If the Registry of Motor Vehicles has denied your hardship license, you have the right to appeal to the Board of Appeal. The Board has the legal authority to review and reverse RMV decisions, including cases where the Registry refuses to grant relief. For example, the Board can grant hardship licenses even when the RMV states that no work or hardship license is authorized due to multiple surchargeable event suspensions. In some instances, the Board can even grant full license reinstatement rather than limited hardship relief.

Board hearings are formal, recorded, and governed by standard rules of adjudicatory procedure. Witnesses are sworn, and evidence must be admissible. Legal representation is strongly recommended, as an experienced attorney can make the difference between receiving a hardship license, shortening your suspension, or being denied relief and forced to serve the entire suspension period.

Importance of Legal Representation

Appearing before the Board unprepared or at the wrong time can result in permanent denial of a hardship license, potentially eliminating any future opportunity to apply for relief. Once a hearing has been conducted, applicants generally cannot reapply unless the Board specifically grants a re-apply date.

A skilled lawyer will review your driving and criminal records, prepare your case, submit a comprehensive hearing memorandum, and represent you at the hearing. The memorandum typically includes documentation such as:

  • Work letters or proof of employment

  • Program completion certificates

  • Alcohol or substance abuse evaluations

  • Probation reports

  • Letters of recommendation or character references

Having a well-prepared case increases the likelihood that the Board will exercise its discretion in your favor and grant the requested relief.

Hardship licenses are not guaranteed and are considered extraordinary relief under Massachusetts law. Understanding the common reasons for denial and properly preparing your case with an experienced Board of Appeal lawyer is essential for maximizing your chances of success.